Heart of My Own Heart, Whate’er Befall

Heart of My Own Heart, Whate’er Befall

Last week I saw my parents for the first time.

The day began with the hymn Be Thou My Vision running through my mind. The tune stayed with me as I drove from Cincinnati to Lexington, Kentucky. I traveled with equal parts hope and fear, carrying with me the difficult memories of a painful business meeting the night before. I had no margin.

I arrived at the apartment building and walked down the long hallway, breathing deeply. The door to the living room was open. Mom was seated in her recliner and Dad was in the kitchen getting her some ice water. They both looked up, puzzled. Dad asked, “Now, who are you?” I said, “It’s your child Dad, it’s your second born.” He asked again and I answered, “It’s me, Paula.” Dad said, “Oh my!” I walked to where Mom was seated and she asked Dad, “Who is this?” I answered, “It’s your child, Mom. It’s your second born. It’s Paula.” With a confused look she asked again, “Who?” and I answered, “Paula.”

With that she reached out her arms and said, “Come give your mother a hug.” As I bent down she proceeded to tell me about my birth, which was more than a little odd. I realized this was her prepared agenda. She was going to let me know that she had been there and I had been born a boy. But Mom had a hard time staying with her agenda. It was clearly a woman in her living room, and the obvious beat out the theoretical.

Dad sat down and said, “Well, you do not look at all like I thought you might.” I could tell he was pleased I did not look like a man in a dress. It made it easier for both of them to understand the fundamental truth – their son is a woman.

For the next three and a half hours the conversation did not stop. There were tears and much laughter. I thanked my parents for what they brought into my life, and expressed my gratitude that they had allowed me to visit. There were difficult moments. With tears in his eyes Dad asked, “Why do you believe you are a woman?” He listened intently as I explained why people are transgender. This 93-year-old man expressed far more openness and understanding than many fundamentalists one-third his age. Most evangelicals come at the subject self-referentially. “Look what you did to me.” They almost never ask about the pain I must have suffered for all those years. It’s all about their shock and dismay. Dad had moved beyond that. He wanted to be sure he understood every single word I said. His openness warmed my heart.

Mom made a few half-hearted attempts to return to her agenda but she couldn’t help herself. When I remarked on my affection for the cups and saucers on the shelf, she said to Dad, “Well Dave, she wants some of those cups and saucers. I told her to mark the ones she wants with her name.” Every time she referred to me in the third person, she correctly gendered me. It was obvious a female was in her presence, and she responded accordingly.

I had a chance to tell both of my parents what I appreciated about them. I thanked Dad for his gentleness, kindness, love, patience, steadfastness and loyalty. I thanked Mom for her tenacity, intelligence, sense of humor and intellectual curiosity. As our time together wound down, Mom said, “Well my lands, I don’t think I’ve had this many compliments in years.”

At one point deep into the conversation I asked my parents why they had decided to see me. Mom playfully said, “Well, I’ve heard it said that sometimes people die in their 90s, so I figured we’d better get together.” Through tears Dad said, “I was afraid we would never see you again.”

I gingerly stepped behind their chairs to position myself for pictures. Then I prepared to leave. I gave Mom a long hug and whispered that I loved her. Mom rarely ever said to me, “I love you.” She always stuck with the less emphatic “Love you.” This time Mom said, “I love you.”

I hugged Dad for the longest time and we both cried. He too said, “I love you,” not words I often heard from my father. I told them I’d be back in a couple of months and look forward to seeing them again.

As I walked down the hallway I kept saying, “Breathe Paula, breathe.” After an enjoyable first visit with my brother (I’ll write about that another time) I headed to my cousin Jane’s home in Richmond. She and John greeted me with quiche and salad and snicker doodles and Jane cried with me late into the evening.

I wrote my friend Christy and thanked her for reminding me that loving is best, even when it is not reciprocated, because you never know when God might change a heart, sometimes even yours.

15 thoughts on “Heart of My Own Heart, Whate’er Befall

  1. thanks for sharing, Paula…you are responding with the courage your life demands!..thanks for your continued openness and honesty…ed

    On Tue, Apr 18, 2017 at 7:55 AM, Paula Stone Williams wrote:

    > Paula S Williams posted: “Heart of My Own Heart, Whate’er Befall Last week > I saw my parents for the first time. The day began with the hymn Be Thou My > Vision running through my mind. The tune stayed with me as I drove from > Cincinnati to Lexington, Kentucky. I traveled with equ” >


  2. What a cluster of gifts: The experience itself; the love and years of all the other life-stuff that set the stage for this visit; and your narrative. Really moving. Thanks for sharing.


  3. This post made me cry.

    All the emotion I could understand and others I could at least try to imagine, coupled with all it took for you (and them) to get to that meeting.

    Then my own bittersweet memories of my own mom, remembering her in her last apartment and the precious little person she had become. But then your photos! All the love, relief and joy pictured in your face.

    I’m sorry I’ve not written you all the many times I’ve wanted to but am often reading very late/early so instead just go to bed. [Sorry….]

    I hope you get this email.

    Big hug.


  4. The photos are worth a thousand words, but the words are pretty precious as well. Moved me to tears. Thank you for this window into your world!


  5. I’m so touched by your story, Paula! I wish for you a life of joy and healing!! You are part of that “great cloud of witnesses” for many who have suffered in similar ways as you!
    The Bible doesn’t say God loves some. It says ” God iS love.” You are passing this along. If love is there, so is the Lord!


  6. That was awesome and brought tears to my eyes. Im 54 and came out to my parents two months ago. My older brother was trans too. My dad told me when I was 18. I knew i was trans too but becided to be the ‘normal’ son. My youngest brother is gay. My parents have no better understanding now than they did 35 years ago it seems. My father told me he had no desire to see me made up as a woman and did not want to lose another son. My dad is 81. Unfortunately it is the reaction i expected. I had planned to go to my grave with this, never tell anyone. I failed.


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.